An individual photo album: Make a photo album with images of you and your father taken throughout the years. Stickers, ribbons, and other accessories can be used to decorate it.
Make your own homemade spice mixtures for your dad's favourite recipes. These can be placed in tiny glass jars with personalised labels.
Tie rack built by hand: If your father has a collection of ties, make him a tie rack that is unique to him. Use wood and paint, or embellish it in the colours of his preferred sports team.
Memory jar: Stuff a jar with mementos or other objects that bring back fond memories of time spent with your dad. Paint and ribbon both work well for jar decoration.
If your father is skilled around the house, make him a tool organiser. Use a wooden board and add slots or hooks for various tools.
Make a homemade beer kit for your father if he like drinking beer. You can include the ingredients and directions for making his favourite beer.
Handcrafted leather wallet: If you're skilled with leatherworking, make your father a special wallet. On the front, you might emboss his initials or design something unique to him.
Hand-painted mug: Have a dad-pleasing design painted on a basic white mug you bought. Acrylic paint or paint pens are both acceptable.
BBQ sauce: If your father enjoys grilling, make him a homemade BBQ sauce. It can be placed in a pretty bottle with a unique label.
Create a handmade journal for your father if he enjoys writing or keeping a journal. You can embellish the cover with his preferred hues or patterns.